It's a story that is familiar to any Madden 23 coins franchise, but typically, they're not even 4 years removed from an Super Bowl appearance with a young team.
This tumultuous period during Panthers the history of their team could've played out differently, had the team won Super Bowl 50. There are plenty of elements that could have influenced how the whole thing played out, and it's difficult to predict the outcome -- but there are two possibilities, both of which could have been realized if Carolina was able to perform to its potential and lifted the Lombardi trophy in the year 2016.
Cam Newton rumors continue to move towards the Seahawks Scenario One The story is that everything is different.
The Panthers were one of the teams in Madden NFL 23 history to win 15-1 during the previous season. They then finished the following year with a losing record after their Super Bowl loss. There's no reason to believe that this occurred. The same talented team with the same personnel and largely unchanged from the best season in franchise history -- yet they limped into the season looking like a shadow of their former self and completely incapable of showing the same confidence that made them a force that year.
There was a huge mental issue with in the 2015 Panthers. They were broken. A season-opening collapse to the Broncos seemed to too closely mirror similar to the Super Bowl itself, and since then, the team was never as good as they thought it could be victorious. Following a close loss to the horrendous 49ers (who finished with cheap madden 23 coins a 2-14 record that season) the collapse was underway.